Showing posts with label conservatism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label conservatism. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 21, 2012

reading retreat

I took a couple nights last weekend at a retreat cabin in the mountains. I finally finished William F. Buckley's God and Man At Yale, and it is a slog. 60 years on, and myself having worked my way through 90s liberal arts education at the tail of political correctness, it's hard to understand what he's so exercised about. I have that problem with conservatives in general, which is why I picked this book up. I'm hoping that in reading books that matter to conservatives, I'll develop a more charitable understanding of a worldview where someone just can't decide whether to vote for Newt Gingrich or Rick Santorum.
"I just don't know, Larry. Do I vote for the guy who hates fags as much as I do, or the guy who promises to cut Medicare and use the savings to build a base on the moon?"
I finally found a couple of quotations that illustrate the thrust of the book. He spends some time establishing that there are actually some limits professors have to operate within--no Communists, for example.
In short, I maintain that sonorous pretensions notwithstanding, Yale (and my guess is most other colleges and universities) does subscribe to an orthodoxy: there are limits within which its faculty members must keep their opinions if they wish to be "tolerated."

Now these limits are very wide indeed, and they are limits prescribed by expediency, not by principle. My task becomes, then, not so much to argue that limits should be imposed, but that existing limits should be narrowed. [p. 151, his italics]
He's arguing in part for what he calls "values inculcation," which is to say that Yale professors should teach the obvious and absolute truths of Christianity and capitalism as the highest goods. You could maybe forgive this as a product of his age, except that he insists repeatedly that students must learn the methods of skepticism and free inquiry...so that they can come to the conclusions Buckley approves of. I thought this encapsulated the idea nicely:
There is great and decisive freedom to be found within the sense-making limits of orthodoxy. [p. 174]
Or, as Stephen Colbert put it:
Though I am a committed Christian, I believe that everyone has the right to their own religion, be you Hindu, Jewish or Muslim. I believe there are infinite paths to accepting Jesus Christ as your personal savior.
I think all I've learned from this is to confirm that the supposed intellectual foundation of conservatism is a crock. Buckley was a repellent human being, and he was supposed to be the grown-up in the movement. American conservatism amounts to saying that the world was created by white capitalist Christians, and that's the way it should be. You can see this in their insane, apocalyptic continuous freakout about President Obama: one popular trope has it that "we don't know anything about him," that somehow the media gave him a pass during the election. Or that he's some kind of overprivileged affirmative-action hire. The abundant documentation and the autobiography that predates his running for office tell his history pretty clearly, but the American right can't accept the true story it tells: a successful, hard-working, self-made, intelligent black man.

I dunno. I keep hoping there's a non-loony viewpoint in there somewhere, and I guess there used to be some: I'm all in favor of making changes carefully and thoughtfully, which is something conservatives used to advocate when they needed a civilized public story while privately lamenting that women and blacks ever got the vote. Now they just lament publicly, and there's a population segment that loves it. I appreciate the honesty, in a way. Shine some sunlight on all that hatred and anger and fear. Maybe we can talk about it. Maybe some people can get a hug, and a nap and some graham crackers.

Then again, Rick Perlstein wrote a great piece for Rolling Stone about how none of this is new.

Sunday, January 15, 2012

reading the classics

I started reading William F. Buckley's God and Man At Yale. It's good, in its way: an articulate, seminal, whining bitchfest about how Yale doesn't do enough to promote Christianity among its students. That was 1951, and it's impossible to imagine they do any more of it now: the trends Buckley moans about have long since taken over the entire Western world.

Those trends are easily grouped into the word "liberalism," although since conservatives have managed to redefine liberalism to mean "health care for poor people" while simultaneously turning it into a slur, we should maybe find some other words. "Secularism" is okay, although I would go with "secularization"; "postmodernism," "relativism," and "postcolonialism" all start to point us in the right direction. Maybe we could go with "peaceful globalization," because what Buckley complains about is the dilution of absolute truths in the interests of every living together peaceably. We can look at a couple of quotes to start.
In point of fact, the argument I shall advance does not even require that free enterprise and Christianity be "good," but merely that the educational overseers of a private university should consider them to be good. [Foreword]
That just pushes the argument off a level: why is it so important that the overseers should think so? He is a devout, uncompromising Christian, so he takes the promotion of Christianity to be an inherent good. Who could possibly argue with that? Well, even in 1951, it turns out, the faculty of Yale could, and did. He makes an airtight case that many of them were inappropriate assholes about it, but mostly he documents how the faculty's religious faith ranges from lukewarm down to antipathetic.
There is surely not a department at Yale that is uncontaminated with the absolute that there are no absolutes, no intrinsic rights, no ultimate truths. The acceptance of these notions, which emerge in courses in history and economics, in sociology and political science, in pyschology and literature, makes impossible any intelligible conception of an omnipotent, purposeful, and benign Supreme Being who has laid down immutable laws, endowed his creatures with inalienable rights, and posited unchangeable rules of human conduct. [p. 26]
This sort of relativism is in part the on-the-ground outcome of the postmodernists' incomprehensible masturbatory babbling, but it's also the result of thinking for a few days and realizing that there's no logical reason to consider your own cultural and religious viewpoint privileged over anyone else's. If you grew up in the West, there are billions of people in Africa and Asia who see things way, way, way differently. It's good and appropriate to make value judgements--I make lots--but you need a better reason than "it's always been this way."

(Interesting side note: what had Buckley learned about "inalienable rights" by 1986, at age 61? He advocated tattooing AIDS carriers. It seems he did eventually stop being a white supremacist, sort of, but I'm very excited to read more of his stuff.)

Now we come to the "peaceful globalization" part. Buckley is railing against Yale's default extracurricular Christian organization, Dwight Hall. The rantiest paragraph is a good one, so permit me an extended passage.
Dwight Hall's magazine, Et Veritas, has no clear-cut editorial brief for Christianity. In fact, membership on its staff requires no profession of faith in even the most attenuated dogmas of Christianity. The November 1949 issue of Et Veritas, did, it is true, contain some sort of a statement of faith by the editors, who "choose the Christian" philosophy, but as a "personal conviction rather than an editorial policy." Later they reminded their readers that they do not forsake their "conviction that the Christian philosophy is the most adequate, the most pervasive, the most conducive to understanding" (italics in the original). Such a utilitarian conception of Christianity, coupled with this brand of self-effacement and steadfast refusal to proclaim Christianity as the true religion (which is what all genuine Christian leaders proclaim it to be, thus committing themselves logically to the proposition that other religions are untrue) is a sample of the adulteration of religion to the point that it becomes nothing more than the basis for "my most favorite way of living." The instincts are fine, and a good life is inevitable for such persons, but so long as what they profess can be subscribed to wholeheartedly by an atheist, we have not, really, got religion at all.
There we have it: "thus committing themselves logically to the proposition that other religions are untrue." It's a great idea! Yes! Live with integrity! Screw all those milquetoast pansies acknowledging the validity of other viewpoints!

It turns out that telling your neighbors their entire worldview is wrong and they're going to burn in eternal hellfire when they die makes for a rocky relationship here, now, in this world, together. This was already making coexistence difficult hundreds of years ago, and if you want to avoid war, it's completely untenable in an age of jet travel and email. We can't pretend that the world's 1.5 billion Muslims are all deluded sinners who have rejected Christ. It turns out the vast majority of them are quite nice, and their world has its own wisdom, bound up in and growing out of its usually problematic texts.

The problem is that every religion insists it's The One True Way, and most of them follow this line of reasoning:
  1. We're the One True Way.
  2. We've given Those People a chance to accept the One True Way.
  3. Because it's the One True Way, they must be deciding to reject it.
  4. Because they're rejecting the Ultimate Good, they must be evil.
  5. Because they're evil, we can oppress and/or kill them and it's totally okay.
I mean, everyone fights evil, right? Fighting evil is always the right thing. Unfortunately the world is a complicated place, and there are actually tight limits on we can label absolutely "good" and "evil" without destroying ourselves. Unless we want to just fight everybody, which is basically what Bush II tried. It plays well into Christianity's in-built sense of persecution, undimmed by millennia of dominance: the world is a broken, corrupt thing, and you must fight it, with faith.

We water down our absolutes so we can live together in peace, maybe at a cost to our sense of identity. I practice Buddhism, which is essentially the practice of learning to see that our identity was never really solid to begin with, so there's nothing we need to hold onto. I don't have a good general solution, except to note that I fall very much on the side of "whatever it takes to keep us from killing each other." Not everyone shares that choice.

Monday, January 24, 2011

linkfarming

I've been busy studying to get a job, but somehow I always find time to read...well, mostly crap, really, or things you would find breathtakingly dull, but here are some interesting bits.

Wednesday, August 25, 2010

rant rant ranty rant

If you've known me long enough, I may have vented at you about the American right's lack of principles. They show this mostly through their language: if they were to say "We're reactionaries who think gays and minorities are inferior and we want to rewrite the world to reflect a mythical period of moral perfection from the late 50s," I could respect them, but instead they claim to be conservative. They're the ones with solid, unshakeable principles; it's us lily-livered, egghead, elitist, intellectual, bleeding-heart liberals who change our beliefs at the drop of a hat in pursuit of our true goal of a bloated government freeing everyone from the need to work.

(Or something. I'm not really clear. Right-wingers are often mumbling about socialism and "statism" and how leftists want to grow government at all costs. In their world, it seems the Department of Defense is not a government agency, and "I think everyone should have food, shelter, and health care, and the government has critical and sometimes limited roles to play in making that happen" is not a clear enough declaration of belief. Too many commas, maybe.)

Anyway, here's two juicy examples.
  • The Republican war on the constitution. This is just the stuff Republicans want to repeal or change; it'd be another long list to talk about the stuff they perverted and degraded during Bush II's reign of destruction. (To be fair, Obama isn't pulling enough of it back, but at least we've returned to paying lip service.)
  • Homophobe fan club Focus on the Family applauds the Wisconsin Attorney General for refusing to defend domestic partnerships, then a year later (to the day) excoriates the California Attorney General for refusing to defend Proposition 8.
As a bonus feature, a Talking Points Memo reader sent them this:

Why, oh why do conservatives over and over again demonstrate little to no empathy for their fellow man until they themselves are humbled? And even then... their empathy is limited only to those in their own predicament.

Take Dick Cheney (please). This man is quite tolerant of homosexuality (for a Republican), because he has a gay daughter. But in every other way, he is almost the definition of a hard-liner in both foreign and domestic affairs: pro SS privatization; anti-social safety net; and pro-torture.

Rush Limbaugh is infamous for the harsh things he said about drug users... until he was discovered to be one himself. Perhaps now he has the good sense not to talk about drug enforcement... but does anyone believe that Rush's experience and expensive rehab made him in any other way a gentler, more considerate person?

And now there's Duke Cunningham [sent to prison for corruption] who has suddenly become a bleeding-heart on prison conditions and the criminal justice system.

The full post uses more confrontational language than I would choose (I often feel like that's really saying something) but doesn't have a bad point.